Jordan Peterson’s New Book, “Beyond Order”

Jordan Peterson’s new book was released a few days ago. I’m sure its rather good.

As the title indicates, he seems to be moving more in my direction. Order is fine, but so is chaos itself.

Reality is fluid, so too much emphasis on naïve, over-simplistic “order” can cause disease & much unnecessary hardship, prejudice & conflict.

The creative mind exists between the tension of fertile spontaneity, randomness, & chaos, & unchosen Thrownness, on the one hand, & the attempt to give order to that well-spring of kaleidoscopic colors & tastes, & forge it into a mold according to one’s Will, on the other hand. This Will is then constantly re-harmonized in turn with the external order of living and inanimate objects. .

The true Order exists in the Platonic Realm of the Forms, which it is wise to strive towards as the eternal model of our endeavors, since with it comes beauty & longevity. If your model is a static eternal order in the Heavens, then you yourself & those around you will be equally long-lasting, assuming no collisions occur with other highly inflexible objects, such as psychiatrists or a pack of raging Leftists.

We also cling to the past & the orders of the past because these are our deepest roots, whose gold has not yet been sufficiently mined, & too swift a progress can mean the unnecessary & potentially permanent loss of riches.

12 Rules For M.A.D. (“Miracles A Dozen”) Recovery: Rule 8


Recognize the ability for and embrace change (express and evaluate the axioms of behavior and belief that have carried you this far)

It is necessary to embrace both the past & the future. Clearly, for someone whose mood is perpetually very low, much change is needed. Therefore, the first thing is simply to focus on this most fundamental fact, and allow it to happen. As has often been said, unhappiness and absence of change is usually the result of some kind of emotional resistance or other. Also simply not realizing that it is possible, i.e. Viewing oneself as one has been told one is by others, as a fixed, known quantity & ‘essence’. As we grow up, our parents, teachers, Dr.s etc, place various labels upon us, which we erroneously, in our innocence, take to be something deep, when in fact they are just meaningless words that have nothing to do with what we really are. It is crucial to comprehend that, at bottom, we are not ‘schizophrenic’, ‘depressed’, bipolar’, ‘ADHD’, etc., etc., etc…. at bottom, we are merely energy, & we can manifest in almost anyway we like, & we are defined simply by how we manifest, in the phenomenon that we make up from moment to moment, not according to some ‘essence’ that we don’t properly understand but that is supposed to be revealed to us in the words that other people put upon us. Again, as I have said earlier in this book, a phenomenological approach to ourselves & the world is the beginning of wisdom; simply observing phenomenon, ‘the surface’, & recognizing that that is perhaps the most important thing. Inattention to the surface, to the phenomenon itself, & prioritization of the opinions of ‘experts’ over it seems to be the root of much, perhaps most, ignorance & suffering, especially of younger people. Once we begin to pay attention to the actual phenomenon itself, to what is, according to a more Heideggerian method, we can soon begin to work on it & change it for the better, & sift the truly real from the fabricating lies. There is in fact, in some sense, an underlying nature different from the surface as it appears to others, (hence why the behaviorists are so wrong-headed), but that nature is more akin to a realm of untapped possibility & freedom, thru’ judicious use of the imagination & learning to rationalize one’s existence more, rather than a realm of terrible circumscribed limitation as supposedly revealed by psychiatric diagnosis. (In this sense, the LGBTQ community have some truth to their position, in that freedom is at least as essential to our nature – to human nature – as even our sexual nature, so the ability to define or create one’s own sexual orientation/ gender is in many respects a legitimate part of that. But if we can define & create our very sex, surely we should at least be able to define & create our own personality as well, which by definition is largely a product of & co-extensive with our own long series of decisions, (i.e. at least partly willful actions ) without being unduly limited by psuedo- medical quackery ‘diagnoses’!) When one becomes very mentally ill, due to heavy external pressure, one becomes like a machine obeying certain rules that one doesn’t understand. One is constantly panicking, & acting in such a way as to supposedly avoid the potential threat, even if the actual threatening object has been largely removed & now only exists in one’s imagination. I imagine this might be called PTSD (Post-traumatic-stress-disorder), or a form of it. It is what psychiatry caused me to have for 12 whole years. The way that I eventually solved & dealt with it was by an immensely difficult, laborious, & slow process of defining what the heck I was doing & learning to re-imagine alternatives, i.e. Elaborating the ‘axioms’ on which my machine-like action was running. In general, it is only by making explicit our own assumptions that we can begin to revise them & change them for the better, so this is an absolutely crucial part of improving one’s mental health. For example, a person who has always been depressed, or been depressed for a very long time, may simply assume ‘this is how life is’. In order to begin to heal, the first thing they have to do is begin to question that assumption and entertain the possibility that life can be immensely joyful. Another example would be someone who believed or who had got into the habit that the opposite sex was just for sex, & that the possibility of finding a real soul mate or emotional union did not exist. Until they address this fundamental assumption that has somehow protruded into their consciousness due to our vulgar popular culture, their relations with the opposite sex (& their sex life) are always going to be extremely limited compared to the potentially sublime feelings of love & deeper relief of which human beings are eminently capable, but often suppress. There are many other common examples which it could be very beneficial to go into, but probably far too many; so always question your assumptions, & try to work out what they might be, & how they might be limiting you unnecessarily. Recognize the ability for and embrace change (express and evaluate the axioms of behavior and belief that have carried you this far)

Intermission: On The Notion Of “Effort” As a Virtue For Life

Intermission: On The Notion Of ‘Effort’ As A Virtue For Life (& The Relative Superior Merits Of Technique) A small child is banging his head against a brick wall. The wise father watches on, his formidable brow locked Into a deep frown. After a long, irritated silence, In which nothing could be heard but the banging of a child’s Head against a wall, The reverent man finally exclaims: ‘You’re never going to succeed like that. You have to bang Your head alot harder against that wall if you want to find out What’s on the other side!’ Meanwhile, a cat who had been Preening himself lazily in the sunshine, eyes the couple warily, And then slinks nonchalantly around the side of the wall.

12 Rules For M.A.D. (“Miracles A Dozen”) Recovery: Rule 6

When things start to go wrong in our lives, it may sometimes be worth pondering why they weren’t so bad earlier; or, rather than simply despairing of ourselves and repudiating our whole past, once we realize how awry we have already gone, & are only just beginning to realize it, it is well worth refraining from despair & trying hard to see the good in ourselves & our past up until now. This can stave off a lot of selfdestructive behavior & self-hatred that periods of transition & growth are often accompanied by. When one falls into downward spiral, getting labelled ‘mentally ill’, it can be extremely valuable to recapitulate one’s former strengths, rather than looking to move forward at a time when one’s strength is very low & new things are very difficult. Mental Health professionals constantly tell us to look outside of ourselves for answers; to go out more, & listen to what they have to say; to take their ‘medication’. But, in my experience, real lasting health occurs primarily through seeing the good that is already inside oneself, & learning to love and take care of it better, to build on it further. If you don’t have any good inside of you, its not clear to me that anything else is going to help much. But we all have good inside of ourselves, which is why we are still alive, as the Universe constantly separates the wheat from the chaff, keeping only what is still ripe for existence. Very often, for some reason as we get older, particularly in our teens, we tend to forget a lot of things, a lot of the things that kept & made us strong earlier. This is often related to the sense of nihilism, of not knowing what to do with our lives, that often sets in around this age. It is therefore extremely important & valuable to fight this dangerous tendency, & think back to all the virtues that we manifested, barely even realizing it, to cope with the jungle of the playground & the frightening, confusing world around us when we very little. On leaving school, one often feels that one has spent many years in docile obedience, putting great effort, & for what? But instead of scorning this great effort we put in totally, we should look upon it in admiration, & as a sign of what we might achieve if such effort were applied intelligently to our own ends, rather than that of our bullying school masters & anxious, old-fashioned parents. Children can also often be quite kind & gentle, then when we get older we sometimes scorn this attitude, since it has caused others to view us as weak & not gotten us very far; this too is a mistake, because it is precisely the kindness of childhood that when combined with the dominating strength of adulthood can work miracles of success, that cruelty & harshness merely sabotage. The kindness of childhood only worked such little effect because we weren’t big & intimidating enough to stand up for ourselves at the same time & gain the respect we deserved; even then, it may often have protected us & made adults take more kindly upon us at times, rather than garnering a bad reputation early on. Recapitulate and build on your former strengths.

12 Rules For M.A.D. (“Miracles A Dozen”) Recovery: Rule 2

2) Slow & Steady Wins The Race

Those who panic about missed opportunities & rush to climb the mountain of life without surveying the territory for possible threats will suffer more badly than anyone & feel unimaginable regret. Life is long. When you are young, you cannot realize this. You do not, you will never understand. Take things slow & steady, & what will be will be. You can never force things into Being that do not have their own organic gestation & time to unfurl as they will, like a flower from its bud, from its stem, from its root, from its seed. The aim of life is not to act; it is to grow actions, through persistent inward attention and focus, from the soil of understanding and Will, and merely seize the moment when they are fully ripe Don’t grasp at life; let it fall naturally & effortlessly under your clasp. Being, the feeling of being alive, of being secure in life, emerges gradually from meditative awareness of existence, over months & years. You will not be the same person at 30 as you were at 20. Let life happen; give it a chance. Don’t sabotage it from a needy sense of emptiness by rushing into addictions to try to desperately fill it up, as that is precisely what will keep it empty, if anything ever will. Rather, let it be filled by faith, & faith in the passing of years & the unfurling of your personal destiny & mission. Life is long. Plant your seeds & they will grow one day, like you never even expected or dared hope. That is the greatest beauty of being alive. As I said, people will try to tear you down once you begin to spread your wings, so, be prepared & be cautious; but don’t let that stop you. Slow & steady wins the race.

12 Rules For M.A.D. (“Miracles A Dozen) Recovery: Rule 1

Image for post

1) Believe In Your Own Star (Form An Unshakable Attachment To Life)

“With life, no matter what you do, you are all in.” — Jordan Peterson

In some sense, I was always very attached to life. I had a lot of life in me, and a very vague, dim, but also rather lofty and grand — extremely so perhaps — lingering hope for the future somewhere deep inside me. At a more conscious level, I was lost for years in doubt, nihilism and despair. I was a like a farmer who had been given a plot of land to tend and sow, but instead was just standing there, sighing ‘What is the point of sowing these seeds? What does it all matter anyway’. Then, suddenly, this plot came under attack and became highly threatened by wild beasts — a marauding herd — and, suddenly, I became highly, highly concerned and motivated with holding on with all my might to this once seemingly accursed and almost pointless plot of land, the only property I had — the only slim chance I had at anything. My very life. The sooner you realize that this is the way it is, the better. As Martin Heidegger said, the way to embrace life to the fullest is to face squarely your own mortality. Then grab Being by the horns. There’s nothing else & you can’t make it go away or otherwise by demuring from life. You won’t remain free from sin by avoiding embracing life in all its injustice & cruelty; you will only sin a thousand times worse. To reject life is to fail to ‘Love Your God’. God is the Universe. To fail to love it is to go through the motions and avoid your responsibilities, avoid facing reality. Nietzsche & Jesus meant exactly the same thing. What you are most afraid of is usually not your own troubles, but your own possibilities; that if you allow yourself to begin to rise & achieve your dreams, others will try tear you down. Which they often do. But always remember, when you give yourself license to believe in yourself & shoot for the stars, far from being ‘narcisistic’, you are actually unconsciously communicating to others that they have license to do the same, which is the most philanthropic of gestures. ( Zizek on False Modesty: On Sabbath, Jewish believers meet in a synagogue and each of them says something. First, a big Rabbi says ‘Oh my Gd, I am not worthy of your attention G-d.’ Then, a rich Jewish merchant comes and says ‘Oh my G-d, I am also nobody, don’t even consider me, I am also not worthy of your attention.’ Then, I hope you know the joke, a poor Jew stands up and stands up and says: ‘G-d, I am also a nobody.’ The rich merchant kicks the Rabbi and says: ‘who is this guy that he thinks he can also say that he is a nobody! ) Do not feel over-run by the Group; the Truth, the Power all lies within the single, fully activated human mind, & there alone. The Group is just a miracle army or rescue-brigade you can utilize. Furtherfore, if you begin to have confidence, faith, that good things will happen to you, & focus on them, they are much more likely to occur. By all means be wary, but only within the context of a fundamental faith in the safety of your own actions & affirmation of life. Believe in your own Star.